What are Journals for?

10 Apr What are Journals for?

For instance, a journal with a niche focus might have lower citation numbers but still hold immense value within its specialized community. Altmetrics have emerged as a complementary approach, capturing the attention a paper garners on social media platforms, news outlets, and online forums. These metrics provide a broader view of a paper’s influence beyond academia, offering insights into its societal impact. Tools like Altmetric.com and Plum Analytics are instrumental in tracking these alternative metrics, highlighting papers that resonate with a broader audience. Scientific journals are essential platforms for scientists to share their work with the global community.

Regular Papers

A peer-reviewed journal is one that is reviewed by persons who are not members of the editorial board and who are not paid employees of the journal. The reviewers are “peers” of the authors in the sense that they have comparable academic or professional experience and are thus qualified to meaningfully critique the quality of the article. The decision whether or not to publish an article normally depends primarily on the judgment of the reviewers, though the editors arbitrate between – and sometimes override – the reviewers’ decisions.

• Hence, it is useful to look up the websites of potential journals for various possibilities before making a choice.
• For each play in question, a coach or team representative provides question or comment about how officials handled it.
• In most other library databases you use, you’ll find them on the left side of the screen.
• Instead, it is a part of what is collectively called the scientific literature, a global archive of scientific knowledge.

Scientific journals also provide a means for other scientists to respond to the work they publish; like what is irs form w many newspapers and magazines, most scientific journals publish letters from their readers. Within a scientific article, scientists present their research questions, the methods by which the question was approached, and the results they achieved using those methods. In addition, they present their analysis of the data and describe some of the interpretations and implications of their work.

Learning to read scientific articles is a skill, and like any other skill, it requires practice and experience to master. All of these journals play a critical role in the advancement of science and dissemination of information (see our Utilizing the Scientific Literature module for more information). However, to understand how science is disseminated through these journals, you must first understand how the articles themselves are formatted and what information they contain. While some details about format vary between journals and even between articles in the same journal, there are broad characteristics that all scientific journal articles share.

Box 16.2 Calculation of the Impact Factor of a Journal

These journals tend to publish broad-based research focused on specific disciplines, such as chemistry, geology, neurology, nuclear physics, etc. In HOLLIS, for example,  opening up an article record often presents you with an algorithmically-generated short list of  recommended reading. For books, HOLLIS offers a shelf view option (at the bottom of the item record, not the side). Many journal databases now provide complete full-text of the materials they contain.

• These megajournals complement niche journals by providing online platforms for research, and accept a broad range of articles and topics.
• For example, the abstract of an article will summarize its key points, but this section can often be dense and difficult to understand.
• Prestige of an author often depends on the quality and prestige of the journal in which their papers are published.
• The officiating-review sheets of the Tech-Colorado game were attached to those of three other Big 12 games on Nov. 9.
• The importance of journals in academic life goes beyond providing a means of communication and a permanent record.

Burks agreed with the Utes on only one, acknowledging a wrong player being identified on a holding penalty. In the interview room, Harlan said, “We won this game. Someone else stole it from us. Very disappointed. Copyrights and related rights for article metadata waived via CC0 1.0 Universal (CC0) Public Domain Dedication. DOAJ is committed to keeping its services free of charge, including being indexed, and its data freely available. A public charity, IEEE is the world’s largest technical professional organization dedicated to advancing technology for the benefit of humanity.

Engineer the Future. Join IEEE.

Hence, you need to choose a journal, based on how much similar work has already been published, by descending an informal pecking order of journals in the field if there are already many replicative publications. MEDLINE currently includes around 5600 journals—a small fraction of all the biomedical journals published worldwide. Its managers use stringent criteria for selecting journals for inclusion in the database. These include the scope and coverage of a subject, the quality of content, editorial quality in terms of peer review and selection of articles, production quality, types of journal content, international contribution, etc. Hence, journals included in this database are believed to be more prestigious than those that are not.

TWO TYPES OF SEARCH LANGUAGE: keywords and subjects

Unlike the common “Letters to the Editor” of a newspaper, however, the letters in scientific journals are usually critical responses to the authors of a research study in which alternative interpretations are outlined. When such a letter is received by a journal editor, it is typically given to the original authors so that they can respond, and both the letter and response are published together. The team from the Cornell lab wrote a response supporting their initial conclusions, and Sibley’s team followed that up with a response of their own in 2007 (Fitzpatrick et al., 2006; Sibley at al., 2007). As expected, the research has generated significant scientific controversy and, in addition, has depreciation methods captured the attention of the public, spreading the story of the controversy into the popular media. The impact factor was originally developed to help librarians decide which journals to buy for their libraries 4. However, over the years, it has been used not only to compare journals, but also to assess research outputs of individuals and institutions.

“Scientific American” and “New Scientist” are well-known tertiary journals that bridge the gap between the scientific community and the public. However, you need to be able to identify journal articles on sight, that is, by looking at them. Because databases often index every item in a journal, including letters to the editor, editorials, news briefs, etc. As far as the database is concerned, these items qualify as journal articles because they are published within a journal issue. IEEE oversees the publication of over 200 journals and magazines, publishing almost 90,000 research articles from these periodicals in the IEEE Xplore digital library.

Another factor is your publishing objective and whether a particular journal would help you achieve this goal. Your primary aim should be to reach the readership your research is most likely to benefit or interest. Another important issue is whether your work is relevant internationally or only to a limited geographical area. In the latter instance (e.g. for studies on tropical diseases), publishing in a regional journal may well be the best way for your message to reach the population, scientists and physicians located in that area.

The key point to remember about any library database — and Harvard has hundreds — is that it is constructed intentionally. Some things are included and some are not (you’re never searching “everything”) but there’s always a principle of similarity among the information a database contains. The Avalanche-Journal obtained the game-review document via an open-records request to Texas Tech for correspondence with the Big 12 relating to the Tech-Colorado game the same day.

However, the effort is worthwhile, especially if your paper gets accepted by the first journal you send it to and then reaches your intended readers. The numerator includes all citations to any articles published in the 2-year period, whereas the denominator includes only the articles published good debt vs. bad debt in the 2-year period that are considered ‘citable’ as defined by the publisher. Citable articles include research articles, reviews and other longer articles, whereas editorials, commentaries and letters to the editor are excluded. Authors of a scientific manuscript wish their paper to be published in a journal and then read, used and cited by their peers.

LINKS TO INFORMATION ABOUT ONLINE (or PRINT) AVAILABILITY

One such impediment is submitting the manuscript to an inappropriate journal. At the other extreme, the paper may be published in a journal that is rarely accessed or read by those interested in the work. Either way, the authors’ efforts to disseminate their knowledge have been frustrated. IEEE Access publishes high-quality research across all of IEEE’s fields of interest. This online-only, fully open access journal features rapid peer review, a submission-to-publication time of 4 to 6 weeks, and articles that are free to all readers. Since its 2013 launch, IEEE Access has published some of the most groundbreaking research in electrical and electronics engineering and computer science.

In fields where collaboration is prevalent, the h-index might not adequately reflect the contributions of co-authors. Scientists publish their original research in scientific journals, which are fundamentally different from news magazines. The articles in scientific journals are not written by journalists – they are written by scientists.

This database also has a wide reach; its search engine, PubMed (/Pubmed), is the de facto starting point for all biomedical researchers to search the published literature. It also includes abstracts of articles and links to the various journal sites hosting the complete article. Inclusion in MEDLINE increases the visibility and accessibility of a journal and the articles it publishes. These are reasons enough to encourage a prospective author to publish in a journal that is included in the MEDLINE database. They also provide detailed information on the types of manuscript they publish; for instance, some journals do not publish review articles, while others will only publish them if they have been solicited.